This is one time when Mama’s way might not be the right way.

Advertisement

The holidays are approaching and if you're in charge of cooking—or just want to check up on Mama's food hygiene—you may have one question on your mind: Is it okay to thaw a turkey on the kitchen counter?

The short answer is, not really. Of course, you can eat a turkey that has been thawed on a counter, and generations of us have grown up eating turkeys that sat out all night, but it's not what modern food scientists recommend. Instead, both the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) and the turkey pros at Butterball, say that the best options for thawing a frozen bird are either in the refrigerator or in cold water.

If you get a fresh turkey from a farmers' market, farm, or grocery store, there's no need to thaw. However, if you pre-order a frozen bird, here's a safer way to thaw it (sorry, Mama):

To thaw a turkey in the refrigerator, leave it in its packaging or wrapper and put the turkey on a tray in the fridge, breast side up. Then, just leave it alone. While this method is easy, you do need to plan ahead. The USDA recommends allowing at least one day of thawing for every four pounds of turkey. That means your 20-pound whopper will need five days to properly thaw in the refrigerator. Once the bird is thawed, be sure to cook it within a few days.

Raw Turkey on White Background
Credit: Getty/pamela_d_mcadams

For example, a 16-pound bird needs to thaw for about four days in the fridge and can safely last in the fridge for at least two more days. So thaw the turkey in the fridge six days before Thanksgiving. (Also, be sure to give thanks for your middle school math teacher for giving you the skills to figure that out!)

If you don't have a few days to defrost your turkey—or can't spare the room in the refrigerator—the cold-water method is another easy option. First, find a container large enough to hold the turkey. (In a pinch, a large cooler, canning pot, or even bathtub can work.) Leave the turkey in its wrapper and put breast side down in your container with enough cold water to cover the turkey completely. Change the water every 30 minutes, so the turkey stays cold while it thaws. It's important to note that if your container is too small and your turkey isn't entirely covered by cold water, keep it chilled by rotating it every 30 minutes or so. It will take at least 30 minutes per pound of turkey to thoroughly thaw, so plan accordingly. Once the turkey is thawed with this method, cook immediately.

If you're really in a pinch, and have a large microwave, the USDA says you can thaw a bird in the microwave. The agency recommends checking your owner's manual and following the defrost instructions. They say that, as a general rule, it's best to allow six minutes per pound and make sure to rotate and flip the turkey several times while thawing it. If it starts cooking instead of thawing, let the bird rest for a few minutes before resuming the defrosting process. Once the turkey is finally thawed, cook it immediately.