Easier than ever.

By Kaitlyn Wylde
March 12, 2020
Each product we feature has been independently selected and reviewed by our editorial team. If you make a purchase using the links included, we may earn commission.
Advertisement
Credit: Amazon

If the only thing standing between you and a home-baked meal is your disdain for messy baking sheets, you’re not alone. The easiest solution? Add a silicone baking mat to your arsenal of kitchen accessories. Made from sustainable, food-grade, non-stick silicone, these baking mats eliminate the need for cooking sprays, parchment paper, aluminum foil and any post-baking clean up. If you’ve ever spent more time scrubbing burnt food and oil off a baking tray than you spent baking in the first place, you’ll be amazed by how vastly a silicone baking mat changes the game. 

Though it might sound too good to be true, these mats don’t hang on to food, so mess won’t stick to them. They can withstand heats up to 480 degrees Fahrenheit, are easy to clean, and suitable to support anything from cookies to fish. And while this accessory’s most obvious feature is the way it simplifies your baking and post-baking routine, the low-impact environmental element increases its value and utility profoundly. 

Once you find the perfect silicone baking mat for your needs, you can stop buying single-use liners and cooking sprays entirely. While all silicone baking mats are made with the same material, there’s a lot of variation within quality and use. So we’ve curated a list of where to help you decide which mat is right for you and your kitchen needs.

These are the best silicone baking mats:

Best-Rated: Kitzini Professional Grade Liner Sheets

Credit: Amazon

If you’re looking for a product with a built-in fan base, these Kitzini silicone baking mats with a 4.8-star rating and over 4,000 reviews on Amazon should do the trick. They’re BPA-free and can withstand temperatures from frozen to 400 degrees Fahrenheit. And they’re durable too—the reviews section is full of shoppers who say they’ve used (and loved) their Kitzini baking mats for years. Get yourself a pack of two, three, or four, all available on Amazon Prime. 

Buy It: $14 for two (orig. $16); amazon.com

Best Value: AmazonBasics Silicone Baking Mat

Credit: Amazon

The AmazonBasics silicone baking mat is the retailer's number-one seller in the category, with over 12,500 rave ratings. These mats are a great value, and each set includes three different sized mats (9-by-13 inch, 9.85-by-14.76 inch, and 16.5-by-11.6 inch) for only $15. They’re valued for their easy-to-clean surface and overall usefulness in the kitchen, too. You can use them to roll out dough, prepare meals, store messy baking ingredients in your pantry, and, of course, to bake at temperatures up to 400 degrees Fahrenheit.

Buy It: $15 for three; amazon.com

Best Nonstick: Roul ’Pat Silicone Pastry Mat

Credit: Sur La Table

Baking can be messy, but when you roll out your dough on this uber durable and completely nonstick-coated silicone baking mat, it’s easy to control. This mat refuses to stick to even the stickiest of doughs and is heat resistant up to 480 degrees Fahrenheit. Although the mat is more expensive than others, it’s made in France and recommended by bakers, with reviews claiming that even caramel won’t stick. So if you feel like splurging for something impressive, this is the mat for you. 

Buy It: $55; surlatable.com

Best Dishwasher-Safe: IconiKitchen Nonstick Silicone Baking Mats

Credit: Amazon

Though many silicone baking mats claim to be dishwasher safe, this high-quality option leads with this feature. They want customers to know that these mats can withstand anything, from freezing temperatures to 480 degrees Fahrenheit, and every dishwasher degree in between. Verified customers on Amazon boast about this mat’s non-stick surface that makes cleanup so easy, you might not need to put it in the dishwasher at all. 

Buy It: $12 for 2; amazon.com

Best Quality: Silpat Silicone Baking Mat

Credit: Amazon

Silpat is the original French baking sheet that has facilitated the production of many a pastry over the last few decades. The quality and endorsement from kitchen professionals has earned this brand a cult following. The iconic rust-rimmed border has become an industry design standard, but it started with Silpat. Though this mat can withstand heats of up to 480 degrees Fahrenheit, dishwasher use is not suggested. Instead, wipe off food debris and hand wash before drying and storing. 

Buy It: $25; amazon.com

Best for Meat and Fish: Cherainti Grill Mat Oven Liner

Credit: Amazon

The Cherainti grill mat is essentially a 16-by-70 inch heavy-duty swatch of silicone, designed for maximum customization while cooking. You can cut the roll to fit larger grills or ovens, and the material is sturdy enough to use for anything from cookies to steaks. Amazon users are thrilled with how easy it makes cooking juicy fish and meat cuts, eliminating the need to clean up a mess in the oven after cooking. 

Buy It: $13 (orig. $20); amazon.com

Best Designed: Kitchen + Home Silicone Baking Mats 

Credit: Amazon

These bright and colorful silicone baking mats from Kitchen + Home are not just fun to look at, they also have clean white lines and a modern layout to guide cookie portions and measurements along the edges. If you’re cooking with kids, these mats are a great option. They’re BPA-free, and won’t peel, crack or melt even when put to the test in the oven, microwave, or top rack of the dishwasher. What’s more, no matter how many different ingredients you use on them, they won’t absorb odors or flavors, according to reviewers. 

Buy It: $12; amazon.com

Most Versatile: Moyhza Pyramid Silicone Baking Mat

Credit: Amazon

Unlike any of the other options on this list, Moyhza’s pyramid-textured mat can create waffles. But it can also give meat, fish, and other dishes crisp and crunchy edges, sans grease (the extra fat drips down from the food). And because this FDA-grade mat is uniquely designed, artists also use it for drying clay, resin, and other crafts. 

Buy It: $12 for 2; amazon.com

Smartest Design: OXO Silicone Pastry Mat

Credit: Amazon

OXO is known for putting a masterfully user-friendly spin on complicated kitchen gadgets, and it certainly hits the mark here with this guided mat, which guides bakers to perfectly proportioned pie, cookies, and more. Featuring metric and imperial system measurements, a liquid measurement conversion chart, and ingredient substitutions, this is so much more than a baking mat. 

Buy It: $20; amazon.com

Best for Apartment Living: Mrs. Anderson’s Toaster Silicone Baking Mat

Credit: Amazon

If you live in an apartment or have small appliances, this mat is the perfect size. It’s specifically designed for toaster ovens, sized 8-by-11 inches, which makes it great for single servings, small batches of cookies, or reheating leftovers. This silicone mat is fiber-glass-coated and BPA-free, which helps food cook evenly and without harsh chemical smells.

Buy It: $6; amazon.com

Best Mat for Gifting: Lékué Macaron Kit

Credit: Amazon

This isn’t just a baking mat, it’s a French baking kit. If you’re looking for a gift for someone who loves baking or just loves macarons, look no further. This silicone baking mat is designed for baking macarons, and comes with raised ridges to guide portions and maintain the confection’s shape while baking. The kit also includes a recipe book and a DecoMax Pen for dispensing batter, which can be used with six different caps for decorating other desserts, too.

Buy It: $30; amazon.com

Best for Pizza Night: YMWVH Large Silicone Baking Mat

Credit: Amazon

This extra large mat is 25-by-18 inches, making it the perfect surface for rolling out sizeable pizzas. You’ll have plenty of room for kneading the dough, so you don’t have to wipe flour off every corner and crevice of your countertop. The mat is heat resistant up to 480 degrees, so check with your pizza oven to be sure they are compatible (pizza ovens are typically between 450 to 500 degrees Fahrenheit).

Buy It: $14; amazon.com