Yes, even if it's waterproof.
Even though I love applying my favorite eyeliner and mascara, I must admit that one of my favorite parts of the day is when I get to take off my makeup. I start by washing my face with my favorite Cetaphil face wash and, when it’s time to remove my dark eye makeup, I always turn to Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover ($7.79; walgreens.com).
It removes every trace of eyeliner and mascara in just a few seconds, even if it’s a waterproof formula. It acts as a magnet for makeup, stripping it from my face in just one swipe. Since I have oily skin, I hate feeling that I'm adding more product to my face when all I really want to do is let it breathe after a day under makeup. This oil-free formula does the job without leaving behind any trace of greasy residue on my face.
One of the best parts is that it's affordable and available at most grocery stores and drugstores, so there's no need to make a special trip when I run out. It doesn’t take much solution to wipe away even the most stubbon eye makeup, so the bottle lasts for several months. One bit of advice though: Shake the bottle to mix the formula before using, as it separates when it sits.
WATCH: There’s an Entire Generation of Women Who Are Putting Mascara On the Wrong Way
I've experimented with other removers, but I always return to my Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover. I consider it a must-have in my daily beauty routine.