15 Deliciously Popular Pizza Toppings

By Mary Shannon Wells
April 05, 2018
Pinterest/Macheesmo
Pizza. Wonderful pizza. What’s not to love about homemade bread smothered with sauce, cheese, and toppings of your choice? In our humble opinion, absolutely nothing. Even the pickiest eaters love a simple cheese pizza. For adventurous eaters, though, pizza is an endless experiment. It all starts with the bread, and there are plenty of options: flatbread, thin-crust, whole wheat, stuffed crust, French bread, deep dish, and the list goes on. Next comes the sauce, and even though red sauces are the go-to, white sauces, pesto, barbecue sauces, and other creations can set the base for the pizza. And finally, the toppings. Pizza toppings usually start with a type of cheese, but from there, you can pile on whatever your heart desires (unless your heart desires anchovies—please don't do that). Whether you’re making pizza at home, ordering delivery, or visiting a local pizza joint, deciding which toppings you want can be a lengthy process. Some pizza toppings can divide a room (ahem, pineapple), but others are universally loved. These are the best and most popular pizza toppings, plus a few recipes for you try them out with.
Start Slideshow

1 of 15

Pepperoni

Lew Robertson/Getty Images

Recipe: Pepperoni Pizza

Poll after poll, pepperoni always tops the list of America’s favorite pizza toppings. When it doubt, you can’t go wrong with a classic.

Advertisement
Advertisement

2 of 15

Mushrooms

Photo: Melina Hammer

Recipe: Breakfast Sausage-Egg Pizza

This earthy topping can be divisive in the kitchen, but many agree that it fits right in on a pizza, and this breakfast recipe is a perfect excuse to try eggs on a pizza. Spoiler: You’re going to love it.

3 of 15

Sausage

Photo: Alison Miksch; Prop Styling: Mary Clayton Carl; Food styling: Karen Rankin

Recipe: Sausage and Kale Pesto Pizza

Some prefer mild, others spicy, and Southerners Conecuh, but sausage is consistently a favorite pizza topping of Americans. This cast-iron pizza recipe gives you another reason to love that skillet.

Advertisement

4 of 15

Onions

Alison Miksch

Recipe: Smoked Sausage, Grilled Corn, and Sweet Onion Pizza

Whether they crisp up in the oven or go on the pizza caramelized, onions are a popular topping that add a little salty or a little sweet, depending how they’re prepared. Red onions often accompany barbecue chicken pizzas, while white and yellow onions are popular for supreme pizzas.

5 of 15

Bacon

Hector Manuel Sanchez

Recipe: Pea Pesto Flatbread

Bacon goes well with anything (try us), so of course it’s a popular pizza topping. This fresh spring recipe gets salty, meaty flavor from just a few bacon crumbles. You’ll also see pizzas topped with pancetta, which is bacon’s Italian cousin.

6 of 15

Extra Cheese

Pinterest/Macheesmo

Recipe: Deep-Dish Skillet Pizza

Who doesn’t love a little extra cheese for the perfect cheese-pull picture? We sure do. You might want to check with your local pizza joint to see how much cheese actually comes with an “extra cheese” order, because apparently, it’s hotly debated.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

7 of 15

Peppers

Alison Miksch

Recipe: Sheet Pan White Pizza with Salami and Peppers

Green, red, yellow, or orange, peppers add a missing crunchy element to chewy, cheesy pizza. This sheet-pan recipe is the easiest way to serve pizza to a crowd, which is code for, “You should have a pizza party.”

8 of 15

Black Olives

Beth Dreiling

Recipe: Antipasto Pizza

People either love or hate olives, but even if you’re not a fan, you might actually like the salty bite black olives add to a generously topped pizza. Or you’ll just pick them all off. Either way.

9 of 15

Chicken

Jason Wallis

Recipe: Quick BBQ Chicken Pizzas

The winner winner of weeknight meals goes well on pizzas, too! BBQ chicken, buffalo chicken, and chicken bacon ranch are common pizza orders that contain this protein.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

10 of 15

Pineapple

Photo: Johnny Autry

Recipe: Grilled Ham and Pineapple Pizza

Although a debate about whether or not pineapple belongs on pizza can be as polarizing as an Iron Bowl, pineapple-on-pizza lovers are devoted, so it remains a constant on menus.

11 of 15

Spinach

Pinterest/Seasons and Suppers

Recipe: Spinach and Artichoke Skillet Pizza

Spinach is a delicious way to add a little green to your pizza. Another popular green found on pizzas is arugula. Unlike spinach, which is usually cooked with the pizza, arugula is placed fresh on top of the pizza for a fresh, peppery pop. Try our Fig Flatbread for an arugula-topped pizza recipe.

12 of 15

Fresh Basil

Beth Dreiling Hontzas

Recipe: Grilled Tomato-Peach Pizza

Regardless what else comes atop your pizza, a few fresh basil leaves will taste amazing with it. This simple summertime pizza would make a delicious cookout appetizer or light dinner paired with a salad.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

13 of 15

Ham

Photo: Jennifer Causey

Recipe: Fig, Ham, and Ricotta Pizza

Ham is often paired with the aforementioned pineapple for Hawaiian pizzas, but it can be delicious with other toppings (we’re looking at you, meat-lovers’ pizza). For a fancier feel, try prosciutto, or Italian ham.

14 of 15

Pesto

Photo: Jennifer Davick

Recipe: Shrimp-Pesto Pizza

Although tomato-based sauces are the far-and-away favorite for pizza, pesto can make any pizza feel lighter. Even if you don’t top the whole pizza with pesto, a drizzling on top of a marinara-or white sauce-based pizza tastes amazing. This quick and easy pizza recipe is made on the grill, which makes it perfect for a summer night.

15 of 15

Beef

Jennifer Davick

Recipe: Grilled Pizza With Steak, Pear, and Arugula

In case you haven’t noticed the trend, meat is always popular on top of pizzas. Whether you’re going for a dressier steak pizza, a kid-friendly cheeseburger pizza, or a pizza topped with meatballs (actually a thing), beef always has a place on pizza.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Replay gallery

Share the Gallery

Up Next

By Mary Shannon Wells